10 March 2009

PM Cup teams a poor mix


Six teams were invited to the ongoing Prime Minister's Cup football tournament - 2 "B" National Teams from the same country (Nepal Red and Nepal Blue), 2 Clubs (Bangladeshi top division side - Arambagh and a third level side from Thailand - JW), and 2 National Teams (Pakistan and Sri Lanka). This mix of teams is certainly quite unique for a football tournament, but one which was poorly conceived.

What does the public and the national team get out of playing in such a tournament? First off, since the tournament has such a variety of teams, it does not qualify as an official FIFA friendly, thus it will not affect the FIFA World Rankings. Nepal's top players are divided in two camps and therefore lose the opportunity to train and play together as a single team. How do we judge Nepal's result against Sri Lanka and Pakistan when only half the national team featured in each of the games? What do we learn from Nepal's match against a 3rd division Thai club - when surely the Thai National Team will consist of much faster, more skilled and perhaps bigger players? It's like Iceland playing an English 3rd division side to prepare for the likes of Terry, Gerrard and Owen.

Seeing that two national teams accepted an invite, would it not have made much more sense just to have a four team tournament consisting of Nepal (a single team), Sri Lanka, Pakistan and a forth national team? With the money the organizers save from dropping two sides, they could have easily enticed a regional national team to participate in the tournament. All teams would play a minimum of 3 games, the matches would count in the FIFA Rankings and we would have much better insight on Nepal's national team. Seems so logical, no?

1 comment:

  1. It looks like this tournament was organize in a hurry. Also there was kind of competition between two FAs ( ANFA and NFA) who is organizing 1st Prez. cup & 1st PM Cup , somehow ANFA technically supported one of the political party to organize this 1st PM cup.

    I'm agree with your vision about just to invite 4 National teams to play round robin as a friendly basis so that it can be earn points for the FIFA rankings. But herein Nepal people dont have this kinda concepts, just to organize tournaments and make the spectators fooled. Still there's lots of Nepalese soccer spectators dont know the League matches rules or format. I'd realized so many times when watching league matches, they think there's gonna be Penalty shoot out when match ends draw. So country's FA also looks same spectators........

    ReplyDelete